Best Winter Musky Lures: Deep Water Tactics, Presentations

Nov 15, 2026Steven Paul

As we push further into late fall and winter, the vast majority of musky anglers have already hung it up for the season. Rods, reels, and lures have been cleaned and tucked away until the first days of spring. However, with musky season remaining open in many locations, a handful of hardy anglers are still grinding away, battling the elements and searching for bites throughout the winter months.

In the grand scheme of things, very few musky anglers actually fish during the winter. Most have traded their fishing rods for firearms and headed into the woods, while others have settled comfortably in front of the television to consume their favorite sports. Whatever the reason, be it closed seasons or football, the overwhelming majority of musky anglers simply stop fishing once winter arrives.

This lack of participation has created a significant hole in the information available to musky anglers willing to brave the elements and pursue muskies during the coldest months of the year. While spring, summer, and fall musky tactics have been discussed, dissected, and documented extensively, winter musky fishing remains relatively unexplored. For those willing to keep their boats on the water understanding how to approach winter musky fishing presents an entirely different set of challenges and and fresh opportunities.

Winter Musky Staging: Where to find Winter Muskies

Muskies in the winter months are relating to deep water. While I have browbeaten the fact that muskies spend much of their time deep and relating to structure in the book Next Level Musky Fishing, my experiences during the winter months have only reinforced this point. As water temperatures drop, I consistently find muskies increasingly relating to the bottom and deeper structural elements. This makes understanding the structure of any body of water critically important. While summer anglers head out like a zombie hoard to find weeds, winter anglers must have their eyes fixed on structure. 

Once you've identified the deeper structural elements that winter muskies are relating to, the next challenge becomes presenting a lure effectively at those depths. This is where lure selection becomes particularly important.

Best Winter Musky Lures and Deep-Water Presentations

Winter musky lures are, first and foremost, deep-running lures. This fact alone eliminates a vast majority of traditional musky tackle, as most musky lures are designed for the masses, with shallow-running presentations intended for weedbeds, reefs, and other common open-water fishing situations. This means winter musky anglers must be savvy in their lure selections, as well as willing to adapt and modify presentations to reach their target depths.

The core of my winter musky presentations revolves around three lures: the Livingston Lures Kraken, Menace, and Critter. This trio provides me with a family of deep-running presentations covering small, medium, and large profiles. Just like during the summer months, winter muskies can demonstrate distinct size preferences based on forage, weather fluctuations, and their willingness to engage a particular presentation.

Winter musky anglers are often dealing with deep-staging fish influenced by cold fronts and periods of diminished activity. This is one of the core reasons I created the Critter and Menace, as they provide me with two rubber jerkbait options that can be fished effectively at depth while offering different profiles and levels of intensity. 

For example, if I am getting follows on the 10-inch Kraken, a hybrid design combining elements of a hard-bodied lure and a soft plastic tube, I can step things down a notch by pivoting to the Menace, which provides a similar jumping and falling action in a smaller profile. If muskies are still reluctant to commit, the Critter provides yet another option to further downsize while maintaining the ability to effectively work deep water.

Creating this system has allowed me to capitalize on winter muskies in some of the harshest conditions imaginable. Rather than abandoning a productive depth or presentation style when fish refuse to commit, I can make incremental adjustments in size and action while continuing to work the same target areas.

Regardless of what lures you choose, having multiple size options that can achieve the same running depth is imperative. For example, a deep-running crankbait might reach 12 feet but have a 10-inch profile and only garner follows. An oversized bass crankbait like the Livingston Lures Howeller Deep Plus, on the other hand, can reach similar target depths with a profile of roughly four inches, making it highly useful when muskies are showing a preference for smaller presentations.

While many anglers think the winter months are exclusively a game of big baits for big fish, I have found that lure size preferences remain just as variable as they are throughout the rest of the year. The size of a lure that gets a muskie to initially engage, and subsequently commit to eating, can be an ever-changing target. Having options during the winter months is critical.

At times, anglers will also need to modify their lures, as relatively few traditional musky lures are designed to run dependably beyond the mid-teen depths. Adding weight strips, bell sinkers, and other weighting options can help anglers achieve and maintain their target depths. The ability to control running depth is every bit as important as the lure itself, particularly when muskies are holding tight to structural elements far below the surface.

Read the Full Winter Musky Fishing Article Here

More articles